Labour’s tax plans would ‘break manifesto pledge’: Top think tank warns Budget raid on employers’ NICs would be a ‘straightforward breach’ of party’s election promises amid fears Chancellor could milk £30bn from Brits_Nhy
Keir Starmer was warned today that raiding employers’ national insurance in the Budget would be a ‘straightforward breach’ of Labour‘s manifesto.
The head of the IFS think-tank insisted the election document was ‘clear’ amid mounting alarm about the Chancellor’s plans.
Ministers have been openly arguing that only NICs paid by workers are covered by the vow. That has been seen as laying the ground for either an increase in rates, or imposing the levy on pension contributions by employers.
In a new report the Resolution Foundation has estimated that Rachel Reeves will need to bring in between £20billion and £30billion extra in the fiscal package on October 30.
Ms Reeves told a global investment summit in London this evening: ‘Discipline on spending, alongside investment in capital, is essential.’
However, Sir Keir has tried to ease fears about a massive assault on capital gains tax (CGT). The PM said claims the Treasury is looking at rocketing the headline rate to 39 per cent were ‘wide of the mark’.
Sir Keir attempted to strike an upbeat tone as he addressed hundreds of business leaders at a global investment summit at the Guildhall in London this morning.
Keir Starmer was warned today that raiding employers’ national insurance in the Budget would be a ‘straighforward breach’ of Labour ‘s manifesto
The head of the IFS think-tank insisted the election document was ‘clear’ amid mounting alarm about Chancellor Rachel Reeves’ plans
The head of the IFS, Paul Johnson, said the Labour manifesto was ‘clear’ on NICs
He insisted the government was ‘stable’ after Brexit ‘circus’ and would ‘rip out bureaucracy’ and do ‘everything in my power to galvanise growth’.
But he also had a stark message about the need to be ‘tough’ on the public finances – with fears of a looming ‘tax bomb’ in the Budget.
In her speech this evening, Ms Reeves told guests the Government would ‘create a tax system that supports wealth creation and increases business investment’.
She said: ‘I know that providing certainty is right at the heart of that. The constant changes that we have seen in corporation tax in recent years have caused instability.
‘So at the Budget, this Government will be outlining a corporate tax roadmap. We will cap the rate of corporation tax at 25 per cent, the lowest in the G7, for the duration of this Parliament.
‘We will maintain a world-leading capital allowances offer, with full expensing and the £1million annual investment allowance, and we will maintain the current rates for the research and development reliefs which provide generous support for innovation.
‘This is a vital step to deliver certainty and support businesses to grow.’
Businesses have been warning that hiking their element of national insurance and levies on capital gains would be a ‘tax on jobs’.
IFS director Paul Johnson told Times Radio: ”It seems to me that would be a straightforward breach of the manifesto.
‘I went back and read the manifesto and it says very clearly, we will not raise rates of national insurance. It doesn’t say employee national insurance.’
There are also fears that imposing NICs on employers’ pension contributions – which could raise up to £17billion a year for the Treasury – would hammer retirement funds and hamper investment.
Sir Keir also received a stern message from former Google chief Eric Schmidt duting an ‘in conversation’ event on stage. The tech guru said the UK was too full of people who were saying ‘no’ and the ‘delay is killing you’.
The boss of Lloyds banking group warned Labour yesterday not to impose pain on pensions and investors.
Charlie Nunn was asked on BBC One’s Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg if he would be worried about tighter rules on pensions, or reducing the amount people can put into their pot.
He replied: ‘Yes, I think…pensions, and contributions to pensions, is critical.
‘We see about 40 per cent of people in the UK have a pension which won’t give them even a basic living allowance… so we need to increase enrolment and investments in pensions.’
In the report published today, the Resolution Foundation warned that around £19billion of ‘black hole’ Ms Reeves has been complaining about in the public finances is likely to persist.
It suggested overspends on public sector pay and asylum costs would continue over the next five years, adding to the pressure on the public finances.
Senior economist Cara Pacitti painted a bleak picture of the challenge facing the Chancellor.
Pointing to the Government’s commitments not to return to austerity, to meet its rules on debt and borrowing, and to maintain public investment, Ms Pacitti said: ‘Tax rises in this Budget are all but inevitable.’
Spending plans put forward by the last government already involved a £20 billion cut to so-called ‘unprotected’ departments – including the police, the courts, local government and transport.
This was something neither Labour nor the Conservatives were keen to address during the election campaign, but Ms Pacitti said avoiding those cuts without increasing taxes would mean breaking the Government’s promise to balance day-to-day spending with tax revenues.
She estimated that between £20 billion and £30 billion of tax increases would be required to provide £9 billion of ‘headroom’ against that target.
The Resolution Foundation has backed changes to capital gains tax, inheritance tax and employers’ national insurance contributions as a way of raising that money, although the latter suggestion would be taken as a breach of Labour’s manifesto commitment not to raise national insurance.
